As a Native New Yorker, I’ve looked high and low for authentic pizza and I think I’ve found it! I go for the Neopolitan and my partner likes the Sicilian because he likes to pile on the toppings. It was perfect! We even met another native New Yorker who now lives in Ocean City. He vouched for the authenticity of the pizza and he was definitely right! It’s not on the beach, but just across the bridge in West Ocean City and worth the 5 minute drive!